S11 Edgic (Editing and Logic)
Ill attempt to explain Edgic for anyone new who wants to jump on board. We devote this thread to try and pick the winner (hopefully by or before the merge). We look at the editing player by player...
View ArticleRe: S11 Edgic (Editing and Logic)
Quote:Sorry, but the distinction escapes me. We use hindsight in saying that we should not have dismissed the winner, in order to move forward in future seasons. Most guideline revisions have resulted...
View ArticleRe: S11 Edgic (Editing and Logic)
Hey, cl! And with that I go beddy-by. Lookin' forward to the new thread tomorrow, pastor.
View ArticleRe: S11 Edgic (Editing and Logic)
The fact that the show is mostly challenge footage now means that edgic should place less emphasis on strategizing. The editors like to show people untieing knots and swimming instead of, you know,...
View ArticleRe: S11 Edgic (Editing and Logic)
Quote:So it's for the most part the Steph show. And she goes very very far. Other players are incidental to this, including BJ, and including the winner. One thing that interests me is that even...
View ArticleRe: S11 Edgic (Editing and Logic)
Danni was always in the thick of things.......she was the strong girl, and it leaves a memorable presence even if she didn't have memorable quotes most of the time. Sort of like how everybody...
View ArticleRe: S11 Edgic (Editing and Logic)
I barely remembered Danni at all last season. Even in the finale. Except for her one big episode towards the end of the season, of course. All I remember from Guatemala is Steph, Steph and more Steph.
View ArticleRe: S11 Edgic (Editing and Logic)
Quote:Non Edgic note to chaperone, from your favorite (well, possibly) Bengals fan - go Seahawks, please beat the Steelers for us!Non-edgic response...I'm doing everything in my power, believe me!!
View ArticleRe: S11 Edgic (Editing and Logic)
Quote:I'm tired of people blaming Steph for Danni's lack of visibility. Danni competed with her tribesmates and allies for camera time. No, I'm not blaming Steph for Danni's lack of visibility. I'm...
View ArticleRe: S11 Edgic (Editing and Logic)
S11 had a different editing pattern than S9 and S10. Every character booted from Blake to Judd was a medium to major character. So if they had continued with a Chad or Janu edit leaving postmerge,...
View ArticleRe: S11 Edgic (Editing and Logic)
I really don't think people are underdeveloped in the slightest. What do Caryn/Janu/Chad all have in common? They're boring. Since the show is all about entertainment value, the most entertaining...
View ArticleRe: S11 Edgic (Editing and Logic)
The new thread should be up this afternoon, Watchdogs check your inbox for instructions, and if anyone has any questions just message me. Oh, and GO STEELERS!! Come on, how can you not root for...
View ArticleRe: S11 Edgic (Editing and Logic)
To Monster Island we go! Or Purgatory! Can't wait to get in on S12's Edgic for the first time. Should provoke lots of fun arguements.
View ArticleRe: S11 Edgic (Editing and Logic)
--pd-- Oh, and GO STEELERS!! ----- If Ben gets knicked up during the game, or suffers a serious injury, hope they won't complain about it. Oh wait, they already did this season! And just when I...
View ArticleRe: S11 Edgic (Editing and Logic)
Look, when you're a Lions fan you scrap for any bit of Superbowl connection, and since we get to host it this year, we gotta root for the hometown boy. The Superbowl will feel like a homegame for Pitt...
View ArticleRe: S11 Edgic (Editing and Logic)
I was just checking out last season's thread in the Spoiler Attic and stumbled on this post by Unduli as the second to last post in the thread. Quote:I'm avoiding posting in the S11 Edgic thread until...
View ArticleRe: S11 Edgic (Editing and Logic)
Quote:Never doubt the powers of Edgic, we had it right before we even started the new season's thread :)So, the focus should be the TV Guide Preshow. Well, that saves a lot of posts. ;-)
View ArticleRe: S11 Edgic (Editing and Logic)
That's great! I like rereading the Edgic threads both to see how the process has evolved and for my own pointers. By doing this I've figured out my greatest weakness in predicting a winner very early...
View ArticleRe: S11 Edgic (Editing and Logic)
Kudos to AMBERFREAK!!! I hope you don't mind me posting this.
View ArticleRe: S11 Edgic (Editing and Logic)
So then we should all put our s12 pick in here before we ruin our picks with our edgic analysis? Just kidding. I love edgic analysis. (I pick that astronaut dude.)
View ArticleRe: S11 Edgic (Editing and Logic)
Brain: Bobby H.eart: Tina Gut: Aras S11 Winner: Danni (Atleast I got to say it in the S11 Edgic thread once).
View Article
